This is an archive of my Blog from 2007. The posts are presented in format as they were published.

Showing posts with label Skolkovo. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Skolkovo. Show all posts

Sunday, May 4, 2014

Russian IPOs – Review of 21st Week of 2007



THIS POST WAS ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED MAY 27, 2007

Russian IPOs – Review of 21st Week of 2007


Upheaval of World’s IPOs and RussiaFinancial Times of London notes that this year we have seen a dramatic increase of initial public offerings by emerging-market companies. So far during the fist five months of 2007 the raised money represents half of the volume for all of 2006. There were 268 emerging market IPOs, which in total raised $53.8 billion. That compares with this time last year when 184 IPOs had raised $25.6 billion. The paper cites three reasons:
(i) ample liquidity in the financial system,
(ii) a strong appetite for risk among investors;
(iii) growing demand for new equity from fast-growing companies.

It is really amazing – just in nine days three biggest IPOs have taken place: Russian VTB with $ 8 billion raised; the $1.85 billion offering by Halkbank, Turkey; and the $1.4bn flotation of Russia's AFI Development.Russia is planning to have many more public companies in the nearest future. Alexander Zhukov, Deputy Prime Minister of the Russian Government, stated that about 170 Russian SMEs are mulling IPOs. He was speaking at the Russian-American round table meeting in Moscow. And on May 25 Finance Minister Mr. Kudrin spoke about 70 companies in the nearest future.
In the view of this news, it is appropriate to note a small news item published by FINANCE magazine this week with a meaningful title: “IPO Evolved to a Rather Sound Way to Cash Out”. The author thinks that way back in 2003-2005 the Russian assets were priced rather cheap. So, at that time the owners were reluctant to give away part of the business. But in 2006 the businessmen understood the price that the market was ready to pay. And this price was way above their anticipations. Thus, IPOs surfaced as the best way to cash out. As an example PIK construction company is cited. The owners valued the company at $ 1 billion at the end of 2005, now Deutsche Bank, Morgan Stanley and Nomura International collectively think that it is worth $11-14 billion. Even though the owners would lower the price corridor during upcoming placement, this is still well over their expectations. And AFI’s IPO is a very good example.

Russian Economy and Stock Market
There had been a qualitative growth of the Russian economy that opens new possibilities for investments. This point of view was expressed by the Russian Minister for Economic Development and Trade German Gref, who made a speech at the annual council of EBRD governors in Kazan. Now the economy shifted from dependence on accelerated production of raw materials. Most of the sectors of the Russian economy are developing efficiently enough. As an example he instanced the development of the stock market.

This week the MICEX released some data that correlate with Mr. Gref’s statement. It still remains the major Russian stock exchange (in 2006 MICEX had about 90% of turnover of all Russian stock market) and it is appropriate to assess the entire domestic market by MICEX’ performance.

In one year trading volumes increased by 3.3 times, investor base increased by 51%, with 48% increase of private investors.As of May 1, 2007:- 288 shares of 190 issuers are trading
- 583 bonds of 417 issuers are trading
There were a lot of speculations last year that there is a lack of private investors in Russia. Here is the data that shows a drastic increase just in two years.

At the same time there is a visible shift from trading of Russian ADRS from abroad to Russia. Thus turnover of Russian ADRs on MICEX is 1.3 times of IOB LSE’s turnover. That shows that world investor community is looking on Russia, as one of the financial hubs of the world.


Oleg Vyugin in PlaceThis week the intrigue with Oleg Vyugin, former head of Russia's FFMS, ended with the announcement that he will become chairman of MDM Bank. After Mr. Vyugin’s resignation on May 10 there were wide speculations that he is going to join Goldman Sachs. However, the press reported that MDM bank suggested more favorite compensation package. MDM Bank is rated among Russia's top 15 banks by assets. Even before Mr. Vyugin was officially approved by the bank’s Board, he met with reporters May 24 and noted that the Russian stock market may collapse by the end of the year, fix all revenues and then rise again. In Mr. Vyugin’s view this is a positive development, similar to the one that was last summer, when after market’s fall, more investors arrived. He also stated that the Russian stock market is unstable since Februarys this year and this strongly scares investors off. Latest IPOs of Sberbank and VTB add more instability to the market.

Investment OpportunitiesAirports. Kommersant Daily reports that the Russian Aviation Agency drafted a strategy for development of airport infrastructure. According to the document Russia will have 121 major airports and 12 of them would be international transit points. Each of international hubs will host its own airline. It is estimated that by 2015 about 820 billion rubles would be invested – 64% shall come from federal, 33% from regional authorities, and the rest from private/government investor entities.
Timber Industry. The Russian government is discussing the plans to introduce large benefits to investors in timber industry. This due to the fact that timber supplies exceed needs of timber producers by one-third. On the annual basis the forest increases by 920 cubic meters, and only 186 cubic meters are processed. The key question in discussion is that investment projects worth more than 5 billion rubles would get forest sections without auctions and pay 50% of the rent or even no rent at all

EBRD Russian ExpansionAs the result of the mentioned above meeting in Kazan the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) is going to open several offices in Russia and also expand its operations including Far East in its sphere of interests. In another development, it was announced that EBRD acquired a blocking state in SKB BANK that is located in Yekaterinburg in Siberia.

Jack Welch and Russian BusinessmenI reported earlier on the meeting of Skolkovo Moscow Business school audience with Jack Welch, former CEO of General Electric. This meeting was well publicized in Russian mass media and attracted also prominent Russian businessmen. Interesting to note that the meeting was held in just restored residence of the Russian BOYAR (court nobility) where Ivan the Terrible was receiving the reports of his noblemen and often executed them after the session. Mr. Welch told that the key to running a successful company was leadership, transparency, vision -- and beer. This was a Q&A session where the present listeners were able to ask any questions they like. "Russia, with its incredible wealth right now, the only thing it could do wrong is not use that wealth to expand globally," said Mr. Welch. He also reminded the well-known 20-70-10 ratio regarding personnel management, spoke on M&A and reverse mergers. One of the things that amused the audience was his statement that it is imperative to celebrate the victories of staff and to show appreciation. "In my early days, I'd bring a keg of beer in every Friday night".

Advent of Church's ChickenChurch's Chicken - a U.S. chain of fast food restaurants specializing in fried chicken is coming to Russia. As it is usual for the company in some countries it will open the restaurants under the TEXAS CHICKEN brand. The first outlet will start operations in Moscow in August, the second one – in September in St.Petersburg. Church's Chicken program envisions opening 30 restaurants within 3 years with investments of $ 20 million. Experts believe that to be successful the company has to hire quality Russian management; otherwise it may follow unsuccessful way of Subway chain that is struggling to conquer Russian market since 1994.

New IPO Candidates
Eurokommerz, factoring company – IPO in 2008
Korston, group of companies – AIM IPO of its main asset - Orlyonok Hotel Complex – in 2008


Russian Business Elite on the Rise



THIS POST WAS ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED MAY 22, 2007

Russian Business Elite on the Rise

The Russian government is actively developing the high-priority Education national project, and it seems that the Russian authorities are worried about the quality of new generation of businessmen. And it is true – according to the statistics data only three in every 100,000 Russians have an MBA, compared to 70 in the United States. Thus, as part of the Education national project two business schools had been commenced last year. Both projects are backed up by the government and the hopes are they will serve as the Russian equivalent of Insead and MIT.


The Skolkovo Moscow School of Management was launched September 21, 2006 and the Graduate School of Management of the Saint Petersburg State University on November 29, 2006. Both inauguration ceremonies (laying the ground bricks) were absolutely identical and attended by President Putin. It is easy to guess that each of the project is supported by the two (supposed to be) successors of the President – Dmitry Medvedyev and Sergey Ivanov.

Both schools seem to target the same goal, but the essential difference is that Skolkovo is built from scratch and is targeted to focus on developing markets, and the Graduate School of Management of the Saint Petersburg State University is based on the management department within the university. And of course the locations and sites are different – in Moscow the campus will be built from scratch in the suburb of the city, and in St.Petersburg at the restored Mikhailovskaya Dacha. The oligarchs that sponsor these two projects are different.

The other difference is that Skolkovo project is the product of deliberate planning by Ruben Vardanian, chairman and chief executive of Troika Dialog investment bank. Mr. Vardanian did an exceptionally tough job examining 18 world business schools and drafting the plan for his own effort. He has persuaded 12 Russian business oligarchs and two non-Russian investors each to stump up $5 million to finance the school, including Roman Abramovich. Aside from Abramovich, others include Rustam Tariko, the vodka and banking oligarch, steel magnate Alexei Mordashov, and Viktor Vekselberg. The list is really impressive, but equally impressive is the list of International Advisory Board that is headed by Dmitry Medvedev, the first Deputy Chairman of the Russian Government. And Patricia M. Cloherty, Chairman and CEO of Delta Private Equity Partners, LLC, manager of the U.S. Russia Investment Fund and Delta Russia Fund, L.P. is also there.

Here are the key highlights of Skolkovo Moscow School of Management:
- Construction of the school is expected to total $128 million, with another $100 million being spent into an endowment. An additional $32 million - miscellaneous costs, while the government has agreed to set aside 1.5 billion rubles for the school from its national projects budget. The campus will open in September 2009. The end of construction date is 2012.
- There would be four options: customized programs (oriented towards specific corporation); short-time open programs (for specific managers); full-time MBA and Еxecutive MBA. Full-time MBA is targeted towards managers aged 26-30 that already worked in business.
- There would be 10 Russian professors and 20 non-Russian professors along with 70-100 visiting faculty, largely from business schools in other emerging economies.
- The process will start with a small group of short-time program in 2007, and with a pilot 25- or 50 students enrolled on the 18-month full-time MBA in 2008.
- Being enrolled at Skolkovo will be the preserve of the few - it will take no more than 300 Russian and international students a year. On the average, the fee is supposed to be about $ 50,000
- A group of Russia's most famous oligarchs has agreed to lecture and teach a small number of classes drawing on their own life experience every year. Roman Abramovich is in the list.
- Students from other leading emerging markets such as India, China and Brazil will be encouraged to enroll, while the Russia-based students will take part in six-month exchange programs in these countries as part of the two-year MBA program.
Despite its infancy stage, the Skolkovo Moscow School had carried a number of events, the recent one being a meeting with Jack Welch, former CEO of General Electric with about 120 representatives of the Russian business elite in Moscow.

The St.Petersbug school of management is also active. However, they are still raising required $ 200 million.
These new developments are really encouraging and we all hope that very soon we will have a good and prestigious business schools rated worldwide.